Some months ago Mabel’s Nana Debs began making various outfits for a Barbie doll she had previously bought for Mabel as a gift, to play with at her and Grandad John’s house when Mabel was a little older.
Debs’s passion and skill for mini garment crafting resulted in her being asked to discuss her hobby and design process (Debs creates every outfit herself and not from a pattern) at her local Women’s Institute meeting. The talk was a sell-out – in that there were not nearly enough seats and the popularity of Mattel’s global cultural icon came as a surprise to everyone, not least Debs herself.
It never occurred to me to mind that Mabel would essentially be encouraged to play with Barbie. Or at least, to be perfectly honest, I simply hadn’t really considered the prospect at all.
That was until quite coincidently, I overheard some Mums in the queue at Costa having a rather heated debate on the pros and cons of the original blonde bombshell and her unquestionably unrealistic body proportions. One was quite adamant Barbie’s aesthetics alone were, in her opinion, not something she would want her daughter to feel she had to aspire to. The other was more focussed on Barbie’s rather impressive curriculum vitae – whatever your concerns are over her plastic exterior, apparently she knows how to succeed in every career path available.
Had it not been for an imminent opticians appointment I would have obviously endeavoured to make my latte last as long as possible and continue to eavesdrop in a completely non creepy way.
When I returned home after having my eyeballs prodded to within an inch of my life I decided that obviously, I had to not only share Debs’s rather impressive Barbie wardrobe additions, but also ask our readers their thoughts. Is Barbie a negative influence on a young and undoubtedly impressionable audience or could she potentially encourage our children that ahem, anything is possible? (I write this with a wry smile and a generous dose of tongue-in-cheek)
Before you compile your response, do take a look at Mattel’s recent “Imagine The Possibilities” campaign. I have also gone all double whammy and delved into more detail on the history of Barbie and her changing body shape on Rock My Style if you fancy a butchers.
As a kid I had several Barbie dolls. I also had a remote control car, a scalextric track, a nintendo and a vast collection of fimo modelling clay. I like to think I spent an equal amount of time playing with each. As well as often having my head in a book.
My Barbie always had her own money making venture of some kind and my Grandad Stan would indulge me in my latest entrepreneurial desires and build whatever he could out of MDF and super glue. There was a hairdressers, a veterinary surgery, a bakery (the fimo I mentioned? I made teeny tiny battenberg and chocolate eclairs – totes artisan) and a metre long catwalk where she showcased her range of strapless metallic puffball dresses fashioned entirely from the foil wrapping I collected from Easter eggs. Christian Lacroix? he ain’t got nothin’ on Barbs and I.
One of the pinnacles of my Barbie years was when my Aunty and Uncle emigrated to America, I was subsequently gifted with all of my cousin’s accessories, including a Malibu mansion (complete with working shower! and a lift!) a speedboat, a Ferrari and a camper van. This took up the majority of my parents conservatory. I’m not sure they were anywhere near as impressed as I was was with Barbie’s ever expanding estate.
Sadly my Grandad passed away several months before James and I’s wedding, he never got to witness the initial creation and subsequent evolution of Rock My Ltd. I like to think that his dedication to the somewhat controversial doll’s business acumen, which was based entirely on the over active imagination of his granddaughter, was even in some small way responsible for this company and it’s amazing community that exists today.
Honestly? I think role play for kids is great. I think toys that expand their creativity and enable them to learn and grow are great. Barbie specifically? let’s face it, her aesthetics are so entirely unrealistic they verge on the bizarre. But then I think that about the majority of “dolls” and Disney movie heroines. Would I prevent Mabel playing with Barbie? Not at all. But I would also encourage her to choose her own extra curricular adventures, whatever they might include or involve.
All said and done as a child did I ever feel I ever wanted to be Barbie? No. I wanted to be Inspector Gadget. Because what’s a closet full of shoes and the promise of eternal youth when you can have a hat that transforms into a helicopter?
I loved my peaches and cream barbie and Ken. I loved her long legged stream lined body and actually didn’t think she needed to be be made into different body shapes. To me she was just a doll that I could put in wonderful dresses she flounced around Sindys apartment in. Her influence on me was a love for dresses, make up and accessories. I think adults worry about it to much. She wasn’t my only toy and my play things were varied. Lego being a favourite along with my spirograph and fashion wheel. I am much more concerned about the evolution of dressing little girls in pink and the genderisation of toys which I missed out on. I think this has a much more negative effect than Barbies waist
Helen I loved Fashion Wheel! an Spirograph! It’s all coming back to me now.
I also had peaches and cream Barbie, that dress with the glitter bodice and chiffon ballgown skirt was THE BEST. So very 90’s bridesmaid-esque x
Firstly, Nana Debs is immense. Can she whip up a few adult sized creations please? We always had Barbies and played for hours coming up with stories. Molly’s absolute favourite toy is Barbie. She first played with them at a toddler group I think and just loved them so last year for her birthday and Christmas it was all she wanted. She spends hours swapping the dresses around but I do listen to her too and she is creating little scenarios. Granted, they mostly involve her wishing she had a ken doll for them to marry! I don’t actually mind her playing with them and hope it won’t affect her body image. My body image worries certainly aren’t from Barbie, more the people I’m around and the copious amazing Instagram beauties I see daily. I think i may just change my feed to be full of cake! xx
How amazing is Nana Debs!
I loved Barbie. Still do. But as you say, she’s not the only character that gives an unrealistic body image. I also loved He-Man figures as a kid, but did I go on to lust after muscley men, the colour of ronseal with blonde bobbed hair… well, I’m still working on Lee to get that sorted! ?x
Ha ha hahahahaha
I actually thought Ken was uber cheesy, even at 6 years old. He reminded me of that bloke from Scooby Doo – I didn’t like him either, I much preferred Shaggy.
In fact my Barbie dated Paul (erm…Cindy’s boyfriend, he was tall, dark and handsome). I’m not sure what that says about me, and that fact I founded Rock My Wedding….
??
Hahaha! James is your Paul ??
You’ve just reminded me that we used to use football stickers and pretend they were windows with our Barbies admirers (the footballer’s faces) peering in at them!! Um…
xx
I think this is a really interesting and complex question. Silvia likes her baby dolls (and worryingly feeds them to her toy crocodile…) but is too little for Barbie. I played with Barbies alongside other toys, but regularly cut their hair to make them more like me (I wasn’t allowed long hair as I was such a pain about brushing it…) so I guess that was a concern, to analyse baby me!
I like what Mattel are doing introducing new body shapes, and frankly I think there are far more pernicious and dangerous patriarchal products for little girls: a recent study of Disney showed that even supposedly empowering films like Mulan or Beauty and the Beast allocated speech to female characters a tiny proportion of the time. Does that teach girls their voices aren’t worth listening to? I don’t know.
Once you spot the problems you see them everywhere- S and I often watch Andy’s Prehistoric Adventure and if he tells his simpering assistant to stay here and tidy up one more time I will pop! There’s a female boss but she’s a dominatrix bitch character which Is a horrible sexist stereotype. Paw Patrol- less female pups. Chugging ton- helpless female train. It drives me nuts!
If you are looking for different dolls, you might like one designed with some archaeology friends of mine: her name is Fossil Hunter Lottie and she is awesome!
Lucy that’s really interesting, I wasn’t aware of this Disney study, or some of the programmes you mention….”Stay there and tidy up”? Oh My Goodness. Fossil Hunter Lottie sounds amazing! x
I used to love my Cindy doll (i had the original before she had a makeover and looked more like Barbie). I never wanted to be her, I understood she was just a doll but I loved creating scenarios for her and making clothes and redesigning her house using wallpaper samples and scrap fabrics. I wanted to look like another Cindy/Cyndi (Lauper) and used to makeover my Cindy doll to look like her(orange felt top hair dye anyone). I think dolls are just a vehicle to express imagination and the bulk of negative body images come from the media . As the Mumma of a baby girl I will try my hardest not to pass on my hangups, more importantly, and encourage her to be whatever and whoever she wants to be. I mean after all hasn’t Barbie had a very varied career, she’s obviously got brains as well as beauty.
All that being said, have you seen the amazing transformation these (horrendously over made up) Bratz dolls go through with their makeunders https://m.facebook.com/treechangedolls
“I think dolls are just a vehicle to express imagination and the bulk of negative body images come from the media”
Jo I completely agree. The Bratz dolls have always given me the creeps, although I’m definitely fascinated by this make-under you mention *goes off to have a look*
Despite being a bit of a rampant feminist, I’m really not fussed about my daughter playing with Barbie or watching Disney films. An I’m buying her a dolls house for her next birthday (although I am painting over the pink – but that’s my aesthetic taste rather than a gender issue).
I think if you make an issue of these things they become bigger issues. I’d like to think we’ll take her out and about enough that she will experience enough of the wider world and be exposed to different things that she can make up her own mind. I am her biggest female influence so providing I do my job and she sees a healthy relationship of mutual respect between my husband and I, she see’s that I am not ashamed of my body, then I feel like I’ve done my job.
Her favourite toys are currently building bricks, Duplo, paints, jigsaws and books. She plays with her kitchen a lot which some people might think is a gendered sterotype but she also knows the calls of different birds and goes hunting for bugs in the garden. I’d be happy with a similar balance as she grows up.
Toys and television are such a small part of a child’s upbringing (or should be) that it shouldn’t matter.
For the record am not a screen time limiting parent…..God forbid….but we do make a point of going out every weekend so she’s not before a TV for hours on end
My old Barbie’s are in an old box full of treasures that I take with me wherever I move – my mum knitted and crocheted loads of eighties dresses and accessories that I still have and I’m sure that when the time comes I will pass these on to my daughter. I did/do have some concerns about what impression Barbie, her tiny waist and perky boobs will leave on Effie but I tried to hide from the unstoppable behemoth that is Frozen and failed miserably! The comparisons between good old Barbie and Queen Elsa are endless and so I think it’s time to stop fighting it and just go with whatever makes my little budding princess happy. I figure between Queen Elsa, Doc McStuffins, Raa-Raa and Postman Pat we’ll find a balance.
p.s is Nana Debs planning on making those Barbie clothes in big versions soon? I think she’ll have a queue!!
Liz I was VERY taken with the suede boots, I want a pair of those in my size!
And yes, it’s all about balance, mabel hasn’t quite discovered Disney as yet but I’m sure it will be any time now! x
I never considered Barbie’s size and proportions when I was little, admittedly times have changed since then – a lot! (was it really 25 years ago? OMG!! I am old!) I was much more interesting in aspiring to having a wardrobe as vast and diverse as hers or that mahoosive house of hers that was on my Christmas list every year but I never got 🙁
If I have a daughter at some point I wouldn’t stop her playing with Barbie, I really think she allows children to explore their creativity. I would however draw the line at any type of kitchen, vacuum cleaner, the woman should be at home making house type toy.
As a school teacher I see everyday the affects of pressures put in young girls to look or behave a certain way; from girls refusing to eat lunch, to the tiniest 12 year old proclaiming she is fat! I do put this down to social media rather than anything toys they have played with growing up xx
Ah Michelle – please don’t feel that negatively towards toy kitchens and hovers! My brother got a toy kitchen for his third birthday because he desperately wanted one (that was in the 70s!) and I now see my friend’s little boy enthusiastically playing with a toy ironing boards ironing teatowels ? I think it all depends on what you make of it. Barbie, cars, household. Horses, bug hunting – it’s the pressure to commit to a specific gender that I find really annoying. And the colour divide – all that pink and blue…
Our little boy will definitely inherit my immense dolls house that my dad built for me, and I’m sure he will love playing with it as much as my brother and I did!
That was supposed to say household chores…
I agree I don’t think any toy has to mean more than the fact that the child enjoys playing with it – my daughter has a toy kitchen and loves pottering about with her little pans etc, in no way am I trying to teach her that a woman belongs in the kitchen though! Far from it – I hate cooking, my husband does it all! ? She just enjoys playing with it. I will probably get her a toy Hoover when she’s a bit bigger too as she loves trying to help me when I’m hoovering at home, but she sees her dad use it too. I think they are just learning through play and love to copy what they see you do, it doesn’t have to mean you are forcing a gender stereotype on them. My take is that if my little girl gets enjoyment from something she can play with it, whether it’s a toy kitchen or a train set, it doesn’t matter whether it’s deemed a girl or boy toy, I think these things only become an ‘issue’ if you make them into one! X
I have commented over on RMS so I’m not going to rehearse the same arguments again, but just needed to say – floral Barbie? Epic. x
I was massively into Barbie as a kid but I never wanted to be her I just loved dressing her up and creating stories, which can only be a good thing! And just like you Charlotte I was more interested in being Inspector Gadget!!
My daughter LOVES Disney princesses and she discovered them all by herself. I have absolutely no problem with this (apart from the fact there’s a lot of fighting goes on between the dollies!) and would never try and steer her away from the things she loves. I don’t think children see things the way we do as adults and we shouldn’t stress over it or it will be an issue in their eyes too. I wouldn’t have a chance trying to influence my daughter anyway as she is so bloody strong headed and she is ALWAYS right (yes she is like a teenager even though she is only 3!)
I was in the car yesterday singing along to Lionel Richie’s “Dancing on the Ceiling” and my daughter said “But you can’t dance on the ceiling?!” to which I replied “Well Lionel says you can” to which she replies “But you can’t! That’s just silly” 🙂 !!!
Ha ha Lucy she sounds brilliant…and very similar to Mabel (!) I’ve given up trying to reason with her on most subjects, she is clearly way smarter (and has more energy to argue!) than I do x
I never had a Barbie growing up – I don’t really know why but I suspect it was because we didn’t have loads of money and my Mum was really against us being exposed to things with body image connotations as we were growing up. She even hated me reading Sugar magazine – I had to do it sneakily! I have a sister and whilst I am more laid back about stuff my sister has had a number of issues with body confidence so it only had a 50% success rate!
I don’t know what I will do with my daughter when it comes to Barbies. I personally am not in to plastic toys but since owning a child have come to accept them as part of my every day life. Juliet is 16 months old and since she went to nursery at 10 months she has become obsessed with dolls/babies. She sleeps with a jelly cat bunny every night that she calls her baby and is forever pushing them round in prams at nursery. I didn’t expect this gender sterotyping so early in her life to be honest. It doesn’t bother me but we will make sure she is exposed to all sorts of other toys and activities as well.
I did read an interesting article the other day that said parents shouldn’t comment on their daughters physical appearance so much. The article advised that parents who comment on how pretty their daughters look every day are teaching them that physical appearance is very important from an early age and that boy’s do not get the same level of comments on how they look, which I thought was interesting. Now, I try to make sure I tell Juliet how clever she is as well as exceptioanlly cute. Even when spitting risotto on the floor!
Jennifer I am very conscious of the commenting thing, sometimes I do it without thinking i.e. tell her how cute she is etc
I do make a huge effort to tell her how clever she is too, and now she is older and can understand more I endeavour not to say things that are meant to be endearing….but could be interpreted entirely differently.
It’s interesting what you say about boys though, having never had a son I’ve not really made a comparison.
x
I get where people might be coming from with this theory but it makes me a little sad that parents would purposely try refrain from telling their daughter (or son) that they are beautidul / cute / gorgeous – if anything I think this can only help their body image growing up, to know they they are beautiful in the eyes of their parents. Doesn’t everyone like being told they are beautiful? It’s obviously not the ONLY compliment you should give your daughter, but personally I tell my little girl she’s the most beautiful girl in the world all the time and I’ll stil be doing it when she’s 30 I’m sure! x
Yep, I agree. I started telling her she was beautiful as soon as she was born because she is and you’re right, who doesn’t love to hear it?!
I think a lot of this is just further proof of how hard it is to be a parent nowadays because we’re so conscious of what we should or shouldn’t be doing that may or may not cause repercussions down the line!
Perhaps one day they’ll make a Parent Barbie and she’ll show us the way!
Haha indeed! I do get the sentiment of it but ultimately I feel like it’s another case of over analysing things and ‘PC gone mad’. All parents think their child is beautiful and should feel free to tell them as much as they like ? I’m sure it probably is said more to little girls than boys as they grow up but this is just one of those gender differences that exist throughout life – most wives / girlfriends love to be told they look beautiful by their husband / boyfriend but we don’t generally say it back to them?! It’s just more of a female complement… I’m sure most little boys wouldn’t really appreciate being told that they look pretty but a lot of girls would, so as long as you are praising your children (boy or girl) and showing them love I think that’s all that matters! x
I loved my barbies as a child, but I don’t remember ever thinking that I wanted to look like her or thinking that she was ‘real’. I think it’s a good thing that they are now making a range of more realistic dolls but I agree with other comments that what kids will grow up seeing in the media these days is more of a worry! I think young children will always gravitate to playing with things that they personally enjoy and as long as there’s a good range on offer then let them get on with it! To me it seems just as silly to try steer them away from particular toys as it does to try steer them towards it… they are exploring and discovering what they like and I don’t think we need to try control it that tightly. How we talk to our children and the role model we are in their lives should probably warrant more thought than what toy they pick up and fancy playing with for a bit! X
Sarah my sentiments exactly x
Our local independent toy shop sells Lottie Dolls which are based on a nine year old. You can have puddle jumping Lottie with raincoat and wellies or fossil hunting Lottie! They’re a very sweet alternative.
I loved Barbie as a child and agree, role play and encouraging imagination is such a vital part of childhood.
Can we get Nana Debs Barbie patterns somewhere?
I will put in a request Lynne! xx
Thanks Lottie. xxx